Updated: 05/08/2024

Automated vs Manual Forex Signals: A Guide

forex signals
.11 Feb 2024
author avatar image Chad Smith

Table of Contents

In the world of forex trading, having reliable and accurate signals is crucial for making informed decisions and maximising profits. There are two primary types of forex signals – automated and manual. Each method has advantages and disadvantages, and understanding the difference is essential for traders looking to enhance their trading strategies.

Automated forex signals are generated using algorithms and trading bots that analyse historical data and price patterns to predict future price movements. These systems can provide traders with quick and objective signals, allowing them to implement trades without the influence of emotions. On the other hand, manual forex signals are provided by experts who apply their knowledge and experience to analyse the market and produce trading recommendations. Manual signals can offer a more personalised and in-depth understanding of the market but may be subject to human errors and biases.

Two noteworthy forex signal providers are 1000pipbuilder and FX Leaders. 1000pipbuilder, founded by Bob James, offers both automated and manual signals and is well-known for its high win rate and detailed trading suggestions. FX Leaders, on the other hand, provides a wide variety of services, including forex signals from both automated and manual sources, allowing traders to choose the option that best suits their needs and preferences.

Key Takeaways

  • Automated and manual signals have distinct benefits for forex traders – automated signals are more objective and quicker, while manual signals can offer deeper insights.
  • 1000pipbuilder and FX Leaders are two leading forex signal providers catering to traders‘ varying requirements.
  • Choosing the right signal provider depends on individual trading strategies and preferences, with both automated and manual options available for consideration.

Understanding Automated and Manual Forex Signals

Automated Forex Signals Pros and Cons


  • Speed and efficiency: Automated signals leverage algorithms, algo trading, and trading robots to analyse vast amounts of data and generate trading signals in real-time, allowing traders to act quickly.
  • Eliminating human biases: Automated systems do not suffer from emotions or biases, ensuring a more reliable decision-making process.
  • Convenience: Automated signals require less commitment, as they automatically generate trading suggestions based on predefined parameters.


  • Limited adaptability: Algorithms may struggle to adapt to market fluctuations and unpredictability, resulting in less reliable signals during high volatility.
  • Less control: With automated signals, you might have less control over the trading process, relying on the algorithm’s presets and limitations.
  • Limited fundamental analysis: Automated systems mainly rely on technical analysis, potentially missing valuable insights derived from fundamental analysis.

Manual Forex Signals Pros and Cons


  • Human experience: Manual signals are generated by experienced traders who use their forex trading knowledge, technical indicators, and fundamental analysis to generate trading signals.
  • Flexibility: Human traders can adjust and adapt their strategies to market conditions, enabling better decision-making during unforeseen events.
  • Better communication and customer support: Forex signal providers with manual signals usually have a team dedicated to providing guidance and assistance.


  • Time-consuming: Manual trading signals require a more significant commitment from traders, who constantly monitor currency pairs and adjust their strategies based on price action.
  • Subjectivity: Human emotions may affect the decision-making process, leading to biases and inconsistencies in trading signals.
  • Availability: Manual signals may be less frequent than automated due to the time-consuming nature of the process.

When choosing between automated and manual forex signals, consider your trading preferences, experience, and preferred level of involvement. Both options have their advantages and disadvantages, so it is essential to assess which one better suits your trading style and requirements.

Detailing 1000pipbuilder and Fxleaders

Analyzing 1000pipbuilder


  • High-Quality Forex Signals
  • Experienced Team
  • Direct Trader Support
CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. 70%-90% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs. You should consider whether you understand how CFDs work and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money.

1000pip Builder is a popular forex signal service that offers up to 7 signals a day for subscribers. These signals are sent via SMS, Telegram, and email, providing clear instructions for market placement that are suitable for both inexperienced and seasoned traders. The service is known for its consistent profits, thanks to the detailed market analysis conducted by the experienced analyst Bob James.

The main selling points of 1000pip Builder are its ability to provide consistent and profitable trades, as well as the strong customer support offered by the team. It also delivers a comprehensive performance analysis by integrating with Myfxbook, a trusted third-party platform that verifies and tracks trading performance. Additionally, 1000pip Builder has received positive customer reviews and has successfully grown 1000 pips per month.

While subscribing to 1000pip Builder, customers can choose from various billing options that cater to different needs and budgets. They also offer a free trial period for potential subscribers to test the service before committing to a paid subscription.

Insight into Fxleaders


  • Time and Effort Savings
  • Best Performance
  • Expert Analysis
  • Mobile application
  • 24/5 Support
CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. 70%-90% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs. You should consider whether you understand how CFDs work and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money.

Fxleaders is another well-regarded provider of forex signals, offering free forex signals and paid plans for subscribers. It features a team of experienced analysts who provide technical and fundamental analysis, consistently generating profitable trades for their followers. In addition, Fxleaders offers a user-friendly website and is active on various social networks, enabling subscribers to stay connected and up-to-date with the latest market news.

Fxleaders differs from 1000pip Builder in several ways, notably focusing on providing forecasting and live price charts as part of the service. This can be useful for traders who appreciate a more visual approach to market analysis and want to track market trends closely. Furthermore, Fxleaders’ customer support is highly regarded and known to be responsive and helpful.

In conclusion, 1000pip Builder and Fxleaders provide valuable forex signal services for traders seeking an edge in the competitive forex market. Each provider offers unique strengths, such as 1000pip Builder’s consistency and integration with Myfxbook or Fxleaders’ focus on forecasting and live price charts. Ultimately, the choice between these options will depend on your individual trading preferences and priorities.

Choosing Between Automated and Manual Forex Signals

When deciding between automated and manual forex signals, consider your trading preferences, technical knowledge, the time you can allocate to trading and risk tolerance. If speed, efficiency, and removal of emotional bias are your priorities, automated signals will suit you. On the contrary, if you prefer in-depth, adaptable and intuitive analysis, you might find manual signals more helpful. Trading experiences can also be customised with combinations of both, which could provide a balanced approach to forex trading.

Illustration of Forex Signals, showing trading charts and currency symbols

Assessing Your Trading Style and Time

The first facet to consider when deciding between automated and manual forex signals is your trading style. Begin by identifying your risk appetite, whether you prefer short-term trades or long-term investments, high-frequency or low-frequency trading, and so on. If you thrive on high-frequency trades and have an aggressive risk-taking strategy, automated forex signals might suit you better because they can analyse multiple factors quickly and execute trades swiftly.

Analyse Your Time Availability

Time availability is another defining factor. While forex trading can be quite profitable, it requires a substantial amount of time and dedication to monitor market trends, economic occurrences and geo-political events. Automated forex signals are designed to operate round the clock, utilising technological advancements to analyse the market and execute trades when favourable conditions are identified. If you cannot commit sufficient time to track these signals consistently, relying on automated signals would be more pragmatic.

Observe Market Trend Understanding

Experienced traders handpick manual forex signals based on comprehensive market analysis. This method often requires a deep understanding of the market trends and an ability to make timely decisions. If you have experience in forex trading, a good understanding of the market trends and can devote a significant amount of time analysing the market, manual signals would be more suitable. It gives you more control over your trades, allowing you to strategise and potentially realise more significant gains.

Consider Your Personal Trading Preferences

Automated and manual forex signals have their own merits and demerits. Traders must consider their convenience and preferences while making this decision. If predictability, convenience and time efficiency are a priority for you, automated signals would be the optimal choice. But, if the thought of the ability to control, personal decision making and deeper analysis fuels your trading enthusiasm, then manual signals take precedence.

A picture showing a person looking at stock market charts and making trading decisions.

Reviewing Platform Compatibility and Signal Provider

When weighing between automated and manual forex signals, it is essential first to decipher the compatibility of the signals with your trading platform. A signal may promise exceptional returns, but if it cannot be integrated with your trading platform, it will not be of significant benefit. Therefore, before deciding on the kind of forex signal to use, check its compatibility with your specific trading platform. Start by understanding the technical specifications of your platform. If it supports automated trading, for instance, it can easily integrate automated forex signals. Explore the type of signals the platform supports; some support all signal types, while others only have a specific type.

Assess Signal Provider

Another crucial step is examining the credibility and reliability of the forex signal provider. This will enable you to validate the accountability and trustworthiness of the signals, therefore enhancing your level of confidence in the trade.

Start by scrutinising their track record. Look at their past performance: the winning percentage, average stop loss and take profit, monthly return, etc. Beware of providers who only share winning trades and dodge the ones they lose. Realistic providers are more trustworthy.

Next, evaluate their communication and support system. Good customer service is vital, especially in forex trading, where market dynamics can switch rapidly. Check if they offer support in your preferred method of communication, be it email, phone call, or live chat, and if they respond to queries promptly and accurately.

An essential point to remember is that even the best signal provider cannot guarantee returns because the forex market is unpredictable and is influenced by various global factors. Therefore, it is essential to use forex signals to assist in decision-making rather than the decision itself. This way, you can balance between relying on signals and your judgement and experience.

Image depicting a person using a trading platform with forex charts and graphs

Practical Exercises and Signal Testing

Before choosing forex signals, one needs to ascertain their trading style. This involves determining how much time and resources you want to dedicate to forex trading. Manual signals may work for those who prefer more control over their trades and have enough time for market analysis. On the other hand, automated signals may suit traders who lack time for market study or prefer a hands-off approach to forex trading.

Signal Testing through Demo Trading

To test the reliability of both manual and automated signals, engage in demo trading. This involves using virtual cash to place trades in a simulated environment that mirrors the actual forex market. With demo trading, it’s possible to test both signals without risking real money. Note the success rate of trades based on each type of signal and gauge which aligns best with your preferred trading style.

You could also use this testing phase to understand the ease of use of each type of signal. For instance, you might find that automated trading is easier because it eliminates the need for constant market analysis.

Assessing Signal Speed and Accuracy in Real-time Trading

Following demo trading, the next step is to carry out a comparison between automated and manual signals based on speed. Speed is crucial in forex trading because the market is highly volatile, and prices change within seconds. Hence, the signal must be quickly executed after it is generated to secure expected profits. Automated signals generally allow for faster trade execution than manual signals.

Accuracy is another crucial aspect to compare when considering forex signals. This refers to the accuracy with which the signal predicts the direction the market will take. You can assess the accuracy of signals by comparing the actual market outcome with the prediction provided by the signal.

Analysing the Impact of Signals on Trading Stress

Traders often cite stress as a significant aspect of forex trading, and how signals affect this stress factor should be a consideration in your decision. Automated signals can reduce trading stress due to the removal of the decision-making process. In contrast, manual signals could add to the stress of constantly studying market conditions and making trade decisions.


While the decision ultimately depends on your trading style and preference, these practical exercises should provide helpful insight to help you make an informed choice between automated and manual forex signals.

Through diligent learning and practice, you are gradually forging a path to an elevated standing in forex trading, adeptly navigating the complex machinery of forex signals. You have acquainted yourself with the subtleties of automated and manual signals, identified your trading style, ensured platform compatibility, and have become proficient in selecting promising signal providers.

Through rigorous signal testing, you have been equipped to make informed decisions poised to maximise your profitability. Remember, the process does not end here; continuous learning and adaptation to the ever-evolving forex market landscape remain an enduring imperative. May your journey in trading be a stimulating and prosperous venture.

author avatar image
Chad Smith

Chad Smith is the Director of Research & Analysis here at ForexBrokerListing.com. Chad previously served as an Editor for a number of websites related to finance and trading, where he authored a significant number of published articles about trading and the impact of technology in transforming investing as we know it. Overall, Chad is an active fintech and crypto industry researcher with more than 15 years of trading experience, and you can find him teaching his dog how to trade in his free time.